The Power Imbalance in Workplace Relationships: What HR and Leaders Need to Recognise

A workplace relationship can begin with a shared project, a conversation over coffee, or the familiarity that develops when two colleagues work closely together. 80% of Indian Gen Zs and 79% of Indian millennials consider colleagues personal friends, according to Deloitte’s 2026 Gen Z and Millennial Survey. Romantic relationships are not unusual either. In a 2025 Ashley Madison–YouGov survey 40% of Indian respondents said they had dated or were dating a colleague. 

Personal relationships between colleagues are neither unusual nor inherently problematic. A Springer Nature research study of 316 Indian corporate employees found a positive relationship between workplace friendships and employee wellbeing, organisational commitment and job involvement.

But what happens when one person has the authority to influence the other’s career, compensation, performance appraisal or professional opportunities? This is where workplace relationships become more complicated than they may initially appear.

Professional hierarchies introduce an additional dimension to personal interactions. When one individual has the power to make decisions that affect another’s career, it can become difficult to separate personal choice from professional influence. An interaction that appears consensual on the surface may involve considerations that are not immediately visible to others.

For HR teams and organisational leaders, recognising these complexities is essential to building workplaces where relationships are respected, boundaries are understood, and professional fairness is protected.

When Consent Exists Within a Hierarchy

Consent is fundamental to any personal relationship. However, when there is a  professional power imbalance, it can influence how freely an individual feels able to express agreement, disagreement or discomfort.

Consider a situation where a senior manager develops a personal relationship with a team member whose performance they evaluate. The junior employee may genuinely reciprocate the manager’s interest. Yet, they may also be conscious that the manager influences their appraisal, salary revision, promotion prospects and access to important assignments.

Would the employee feel equally comfortable expressing a different opinion or ending the relationship if those professional consequences were not a consideration?

Managers will inevitably exercise authority when assigning responsibilities, evaluating performance and making business decisions. The concern arises when that authority is used, directly or indirectly, to influence personal decisions, create expectations of intimacy or penalise someone for refusing or withdrawing consent.

Under India’s Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, conduct involving implied or explicit promises of preferential treatment, threats of detrimental treatment, or interference with employment conditions in connection with sexual conduct can fall within the scope of sexual harassment. The distinction between legitimate managerial authority and its misuse therefore matters considerably.

The Problem of Perceived Favouritism

Imagine a department head who is in a relationship with a team member. Let us say that the team member receives opportunities to lead high-visibility projects, attend industry events or participate in leadership discussions. Even if these decisions are entirely merit-based, other team members may question whether the relationship influenced them.

This creates two potential risks. First, employees may lose confidence in the fairness and transparency of organisational decisions. Second, the individual in the relationship may face professional scrutiny, resentment or isolation, regardless of their actual performance.

The implications can be particularly serious when the relationship ends. If one person continues to control the other’s reporting line, appraisal or career progression, disagreements outside work may spill into professional interactions. A previously comfortable relationship can become a source of pressure, perceived retaliation or conflict.

The issue, therefore, is not simply whether a relationship exists. It is whether the organisation has adequate safeguards to ensure that personal relationships do not compromise professional fairness or create an environment in which someone feels vulnerable.

What HR Teams and Leaders Should Do

Managing power imbalances requires more than a blanket prohibition on workplace relationships. Organisations need clear policies, transparent processes and safeguards that protect everyone involved.

  1. Establish clear conflict-of-interest policies

Employees should understand the organisation’s expectations when personal relationships develop between individuals in a reporting hierarchy. Policies should outline disclosure requirements, particularly where one person has direct or indirect influence over the other’s professional decisions. The objective should be to manage potential conflicts, not intrude unnecessarily into employees’ private lives.

  1. Review reporting structures and decision-making authority

Where a relationship involves individuals in a direct reporting relationship, organisations should consider alternative arrangements. This could include changing the reporting manager or ensuring that performance evaluations, compensation decisions and promotion recommendations are independently reviewed. Such measures protect both individuals from allegations of preferential treatment or unfair disadvantage.

  1. Protect confidentiality

Disclosures of personal relationships and concerns arising from them must be handled sensitively. HR should limit access to information to those who genuinely need it. Similarly, when a POSH complaint is raised, confidentiality obligations must be respected throughout the inquiry process. Gossip, speculation and informal discussions can cause considerable harm to everyone involved.

  1. Strengthen safeguards against retaliation

Employees must be able to decline advances, withdraw from personal relationships or raise concerns without fearing adverse professional consequences. Organisations should monitor changes in responsibilities, appraisals, compensation and opportunities where there is a potential conflict or an ongoing complaint. Any adverse decision should have a legitimate, documented and independently reviewable basis.

  1. Train managers to recognise the boundaries of authority

Leadership training should address how professional influence can affect workplace interactions. Managers must understand that their seniority carries additional responsibility, particularly when personal relationships involve individuals whose careers they can influence. POSH awareness programmes should also help employees recognise inappropriate conduct and understand the channels available to seek support.

Building a Culture Where Professional Boundaries Matter

Workplace relationships cannot always be separated from the environments in which people spend much of their time. Nor should organisations assume that every relationship involving a difference in seniority is inherently exploitative.

The responsibility of an organisation is to ensure that professional authority is never used to compromise an individual’s dignity, choices or career prospects. It must also ensure that personal relationships do not undermine the trust employees place in organisational decisions and processes.

For HR teams and leaders, recognising the power behind professional hierarchies is an important step towards creating that environment.